Riki Lindhome

Garfunkel

Kate Micucci

Oates

Creed Bratton

Kazoo Man

Ben Kingsley

Ben Kingsley

Sugar Lyn Beard

Epiphany

Abby Elliott

Chevrolet

Jerry Lambert

Wesker-Wynn Boss

Karen Maruyama

Susie

Tig Notaro

Pumpernickel Place Producer

John Oates

Dirty D

Russ Walko

Puppeteer

Chris Parnell

Stan

Chris Hardwick

Himself

Steve Agee

Toy Store Cashier

Geoffrey Arend

Todd

Liz Cackowski

Yogurt Woman

Camille Chen

Caroline

Malcolm Barrett

Daniel