Jonathan Tucker

Tommy Donnelly

Tom Guiry

Jimmy Donnelly

Olivia Wilde

Jenny Reilly

Billy Lush

Kevin Donnelly

Michael Stahl-David

Sean Donnelly

Kirk Acevedo

Nicky Cottero

Keith Nobbs

Joey 'Ice Cream'

Peter Greene

Derek 'Dokey' Farrell

Brian Tarantina

Vinnie Culiari

Patrick Brennan

Earl

Elizabeth Gillies

Young Jenny

Kate Mulgrew

Helen Donnelly

Jason Furlani

George

Kenny Marino

McGee

Chris Bauer

Huey Farrell

Mark Margolis

Sal Minetta

Lenny Venito

Benny Cool

Ned Eisenberg

Frankie Stein