Barrabás

Anthony Quinn

Barabbas

Silvana Mangano

Rachel

Arthur Kennedy

Pontius Pilate

Katy Jurado

Sara

Harry Andrews

Peter

Vittorio Gassman

Sahak

Norman Wooland

Rufio

Valentina Cortese

Julia

Jack Palance

Torvald

Ernest Borgnine

Lucius

Arnoldo Foà

Joseph of Arimathea

Michael Gwynn

Lazarus

Laurence Payne

Disciple

Douglas Fowley

Vasasio

Guido Celano

Scorpio

Enrico Glori

Man Pleading for Release of Prisoner

Carlo Giustini

Officer (as Carlo Giutini)

Giovanni Di Benedetto

Officer (as Gianni Di Benedetto)