David Walton

Will

Minnie Driver

Fiona

Benjamin Stockham

Marcus

Al Madrigal

Andy

Annie Mumolo

Laurie

Samuel Gilbert

Douglas

Adrianne Palicki

Samantha Lake

Greg Germann

Johnny Idalis

Izabela Vidovic

Shea

Max Harris

Kid #2

Chris Diamantopoulos

Chris

Candice Patton

Veronica

Andrea Anders

joanne

Christian Ganiere

Debby's Kid #2

Reid Miller

Boy at Ballpark (uncredited)

Jacob Hopkins

Eddie

Griffin Gluck

Clay

Cyrus Arnold

Kid #1