A to Z

Ben Feldman

Andrew

Cristin Milioti

Zelda

Henry Zebrowski

Stu

Lenora Crichlow

Stephie

Christina Kirk

Lydia 'Big Bird'

Katey Sagal

Narrator (voice)

Ben Falcone

Howard

Ray Parker Jr.

Himself

Sarah Baker

Jennifer

Echo Kellum

Joseph

Hunter Payton

Young Andrew

Colin McGurk

Barista

John Gabriel Rodriquez

Mike

Lea Thompson

Lea Thompson

Nancy Friedrich

Nancy

Maggie Beal

Young Zelda

Celeste Cook

Theatre Patron

Chelsey Crisp

Brooke