Your Pretty Face Is Going to Hell

Craig Rowin

Claude

Eddie Pepitone

Eddie

Henry Zebrowski

Gary

Dana Snyder

Lucas

Matt Servitto

Satan

Carolann Utley

Lee

Dustin Diamond

Himself

Drew Scheid

Escape Room Manager

Derek Russo

Muscular Angel

David Silverman

Youth Minister

Tim Robinson

Lip Licker

Dave Willis

Krampus

Kevin Gillespie

Himself

Noah Staggs

Farmer

Ashley Lauren Thomas

College Student

Cooper Andrews

Modok